| Year |
Inductees |
| 2023 |
Dave Armstrong, Michael Boykin, John Conte, Keith Ely, Rocco Fantazzi, Zack Fuentes, Brett Harner, Matt Rappo |
| 2022 |
Aaron Brown, Jorge Leon, Mark Marino, Matt Martoccio, David Osei, Andre Petroski, Kim Smith, Jeremy Stierly, Tom Vivacqua, Josh Weitzel |
| 2021 |
John Basile, Brad Clark, Brandan Clark, Chuck Hangey, Matt Harkins, Robert Koffler, Jeremy Minich, Alex Pellicciotti, Joe Stolfi |
| 2020 |
Austin Carter, Dillon Evans, George Heebner, Billy Rappo, Shane Springer, Jimmy Vollrath, Ben Young |
| 2019 |
Michael Chase, Fred DiChaira, Glenn Kaiser, George Kovach, Steve Kovach, Tommy Long, John Michael Staudenmayer |
| 2018 |
Jim Bertulis, Jamie Callender, Josh Dzeiwa, Jim Hartey, Robert Martin |
| 2017 |
Pete Ventresca, Tony Haley, John Cooley, Glen Lambert, Ken Daws, Jeff Cook, Bob Hill |
| 2016 |
Thomas Corey, Michael J. Darcy, Daniel Geib, Bruce Kennett, Michael B. Ortman, Mark Rappo, Douglas Weidner, Timothy West |
| 2015 |
Don Berner, Craig Deacon, Orvis Kline, Edward Matthews, Matt Moley, Jason Shivak, Richard Siegmann, Jeff Sipler |
| 2014 |
Daniel Bing, Brent Fiorito, Patrick Flynn, Tom Hontz, Zachary Kemmerer, Michael Letts, Chris Sheetz, Joe Stabilito Sr. |
| 2013 |
John Armato, Dan Goetter, Tim Harner, Darren Kern, Richard R. Marburg, Michael Rappo, Rick Rappo, Jamy L. Ritter |
| 2012 |
David Burke, Brad Forbes, Jeff Franko, Bob King, Phil Maroney, Mark Smith, Mike Spaid |
| 2011 |
Larry Estep, Zac Fryling, Ronald Nelson, Sid Nodland, Dick Osbeck, Stan Smith, Joe Tornetta |
| 2010 |
Lou Delmuto, Tony DeMeno, Rich Hahn, Alray Johnson, Jermaine Jones, Joe Krammer, John Lute |
| 2009 |
Charlie Kramer, Mike Coley, Joel Edwards, Mike Jones, Rocky Mantella, Derek Zinck |
| 2008 |
Steve Harner, Jeff Madden, Mike Pirozzola, Roger Reina, Bill Stecklein Sr., Rod Stone |
| 2007 |
Mark Cagle, Justin Giovinco, Joseph Kiefer, Steve McGovern, Patrick J. Nugent |
| 2006 |
Mark Conley, Bruce Hallman, Bob McCreary, John Boyd Orr, Richard "Skip" Shoemaker, Ron Tirpak |
| 2005 |
Jude Arena, Gomer Davies, David Evans, George Hollenden, Rick Springman, William "Bill" Vollrath |
| 2004 |
Fred Colteryahn, Charles "Chuckie" Connor, Jack Dunn, Mike Krafchick, Carl Poff, Chris Poff, Howard Sage, Ronald Sheehan, Rich Solofsky |
| 2003 |
Jack Childs, Lou DeSerafino, Jason Lamotta, Art McCall, Chris Potter, William Racich, Scott Stay, John Tomlinson, Jim Tsakonas |
| 2002 |
Nate Burroughs, Dan Covatta, Scott Gold II, Dennis Kellon, John Kopack, Robert Lorence, Robert Marshall, Josh Stanley, William Zimmerman |
| 2001 |
Dale Bonsall, Josh Henson, James Holt, Kip Kiefer, Brad Rozanski, Mark Stephenson, Ralph Wetzel |
| 2000 |
John Hangey, Lonny Moore, Dave Morgan, John Rittenhouse, Mike Salone, Steve Saltzman |
| 1999 |
Ed Curran, Dan Finacchio, Paul Green, Chris Kworknik, Jim Kwortnik |
| 1998 |
Tony Differ, Chuck Grassano, Jim Jones, Chuck Murray, Marc Sodano |
| 1997 |
Michael Bianco, Frank Bing, Glenn Koser, Jon Moser, Nelson Stratton, Al Wolstenholme |
| 1996 |
Bill Marino, Andy Matter, Bill Neill, John Reich |
| 1995 |
Jeff Below, C.D Mock, Kurt Mock, Mike Sipler, Vic Stanley |
| 1994 |
Dean Brior, Don Kulp, Dennis Merriam, Roger Sanders, Bob Winters |
| 1993 |
Pete Drehman, Bob Hallman, Ed Klavon, Steve Paxon, Terry Williams |
| 1992 |
Lee Bohner, John Dussling, Greg McBride, John McHugh, Carl Schnellenbach, James Tufano |
| 1991 |
Neil Cockley, W. Laird Robertson, Warner Seel, Dick Shoemaker, Joseph Tropp |
| 1990 |
Thomas Boggs, Neil Buckley, Dick DiBattista, Don Seeley |
|